In short
- A roof box is the safest way to carry skis. ADAC tested 13 boxes in 2024 and 8 were rated good.
- Skis loose inside the car turn into projectiles in a hard stop. If you must, strap them down and fasten every seat belt.
- Do the math: a good €350 box used for 10 seasons costs €35 a season. The €900 winner costs €90. Both beat a crash.
Skis are long, sharp and stiff. Where do they go? Roof rack, roof box or inside the car? Most drivers pick what fits, not what is safe. Here is what ADAC, ÖAMTC and Auto Zeitung say, and how I would load the car for the Alps.
The short answer: A roof box is the safest option for skis. Skis loose inside the car become projectiles in a hard stop, so strap them down if you have no other choice.
What to look for
- Safety first. In the ADAC crash test, two boxes came loose from the base carrier. That is the number one thing to check.
- Fit. The box needs a base carrier made for your car and must sit on the mounting points the maker names.
- Lock and strength. A box with a lock keeps gear dry and safe from thieves, and a lid that does not crack in the cold.
- Real volume and length. One tested box had 20 % less volume than claimed.
- Weight. A light box lets you load more, because your roof has a load limit.
Option 1: roof box
Auto Zeitung calls the roof box the safest way to carry skis. ÖAMTC agrees that skis belong on the roof only in a lockable box or on lockable racks.
ADAC tested 13 boxes in 2024. Eight were rated good. The winner was the Thule box made for Audi, followed by the Thule Motion 3 XL Low, which costs about €900. Cheaper? The Norauto Bermude 300 at €350 also did well, with small compromises in comfort and size.
The weak ones were Northline and VDP, both only sufficient. In the crash test they partly came off the base carrier. The VDP lid also broke in the cold, and the ski tips went through the box.
Option 2: ski rack on the roof
A rack costs less, but the skis sit in wind, salt and spray. ÖAMTC says use lockable racks and tie the load down. Skis on top also make the car more sensitive to side wind.
Option 3: inside the car
Auto Zeitung advises against it if you can avoid it. In a full stop, skis become dangerous projectiles, and even seat backs do not stop sharp boards. Skis usually only fit with the rear seat folded.
If there is no other way, ÖAMTC says strap skis on the rear seat with tie-down or safety straps. ADAC adds: fasten the seat belts even on empty seats, it can make the backrests more stable.
How to load: step by step
- Heavy first, low and as far forward as possible. Ski boots go in the footwell behind the front seats or low in the trunk.
- Keep anything over 25 kg out from behind occupied seats (ADAC).
- Skis and boards at the bottom of the roof box, tied down. Soft items like jackets go on top and in front.
- Strap down the content of the box too. ÖAMTC warns that loose cargo in a box can become a danger.
- Check the roof load limit of your car and the max load of the box. Rack, box and cargo together must stay under it.
- Check all bolts before loading, after loading and again after 20 km (TÜV Süd, via Auto Zeitung).
- Keep your view clear and keep at least two seconds of distance. The car brakes longer and reacts more to wind.
Mistakes to avoid
- Loose skis in the cabin.
- A cheap box with no crash result. Ask what the test says, not what the sticker says.
- Leaving the box on all year. ADAC says take unused boxes off to avoid higher fuel use and wind noise.
- Overloading the roof.
- Forgetting to wash salt off the box and rack after the trip (ÖAMTC).
Do the math: Example with the prices from the ADAC test. A box at €350, used 10 seasons, is €35 a season. The €900 Thule Motion 3 XL Low is €90 a season. The difference is €55 a season for more comfort and size. If you ski one week a year, the cheaper tested box that passed the crash test is the sensible buy. The really expensive choice is the box that comes off the base carrier.
FAQ
Can I carry skis inside the car? You can, but a roof box is safer. Inside, strap them down and keep heavy gear low.
Do I need to take the box off after the season? Yes. ADAC says unused boxes raise fuel use and noise.
Is the original car-maker box better? Not always. ADAC notes that maker boxes are often less flexible when you change cars.
Ivan’s Take
Roof box, no debate. I would not go below a tested model like the €350 Norauto Bermude 300, and I would strap the load inside the box. Skis loose in the cabin is the one thing I would never do.
Sources: ADAC roof box test 2024 (via Motor1); ÖAMTC: Skitransport; Auto Zeitung: Ski-Transport im Auto.
Published:
More from this section
The AvtoGear weekly
Once a week: new tests, the best deals and one useful tip for your car. Nothing extra.


