In short
- A badly secured Christmas tree becomes a projectile in a crash. ADAC tests show bungee cords snap.
- Germany: the tree may stick out up to 1.5 m at the back (3 m on trips up to 100 km). From 1 m you need a light-red flag, and a red light in the dark.
- German fines: €25 for missing marking, €35 for poor securing, €60 plus a point if someone is endangered, €75 plus a point after a crash.
Every December the same picture: a fir tree on a car roof, held by two bungee cords and hope. It looks harmless. It is not. In hard braking the tree keeps moving forward, and ADAC warns that a badly secured tree turns into a projectile in a crash. Here is how to bring it home without a fine and without a dented roof.
The short answer: Trunk first, tied with ratchet straps to roof bars or inside with the seats folded; over 1 m of overhang at the back needs a red flag in Germany.
Roof or boot?
Small tree, estate car or hatchback with folding seats: inside is safer. The tree is out of the wind and cannot fly off. Big tree or small car: the roof, but only with roof bars or a roof rack. Without bars you have nothing solid to tie it to.
Ask the seller to put the tree through the netting machine. A netted tree is narrower, easier to strap and drops fewer needles in your car.
Inside the car: step by step
- 1. Fold the rear seats and put a blanket or old sheet down. Resin is hard to get out of upholstery.
- 2. Trunk first, towards the front. The cut end goes against the back of a front seat.
- 3. ADAC Nordbayern recommends a wooden board between seat back and trunk to protect the seat.
- 4. Tie the tree down with ratchet straps to the lashing eyes in the boot.
- 5. If the top sticks out, keep the tailgate as closed as possible and secure it. The tree must not cover the rear lights or the number plate.
On the roof: step by step
- 1. Check that the roof bars are tight. Check your car’s maximum roof load in the manual.
- 2. Lay a blanket on the roof to protect the paint.
- 3. Trunk first, towards the front of the car. That way the branches fold back in the wind instead of opening up like an umbrella.
- 4. Use at least two ratchet straps around the bars. Bungee cords are not enough: ADAC tests showed they tear.
- 5. Check after the first few hundred metres and pull the straps tight again.
- 6. Drive slower than usual and brake earlier. The car is taller and catches more side wind.
The rules on overhang (Germany)
In Germany the load may stick out up to 1.5 metres at the back. On trips of up to 100 km it may be 3 metres. From 1 metre of overhang you must mark the end with a light-red flag, a sign or a red cylinder. In bad visibility and in the dark, you need a red light and a red reflector.
Other countries have their own rules. Italy and Spain, for example, require a red-and-white striped panel for loads that stick out at the back. If you buy your tree abroad or drive through, check the local rule before you go.
Mistakes to avoid
- Bungee cords instead of ratchet straps.
- Tip first on the roof. The branches open in the wind and the tree pulls on the straps.
- Hiding the number plate or rear lights with the tree.
- Tying the tree through open doors or windows. The doors will not close properly and the seals get damaged.
- Forgetting the needles. Vacuum the boot the same day, before resin sticks.
Do the math: The German fine catalogue: €25 if the overhang is not marked, €35 for a poorly secured load, €60 plus one point if someone is endangered, €75 plus one point after an accident. A Christmas tree costs a similar amount. Two ratchet straps and a blanket you already own are the cheapest insurance here.
FAQ
Can I carry a Christmas tree on the roof without roof bars? Not safely. Without bars there is nothing solid to strap it to. Tying through the doors damages the seals.
When do I need a red flag? In Germany as soon as the tree sticks out more than 1 metre at the back. In the dark a red light and reflector are needed.
Which way should the tree point? Trunk to the front, both on the roof and inside the car.
Ivan’s Take
I would always choose the boot if the tree fits. Two ratchet straps cost less than one fine, and a tree in the car cannot land on the windscreen behind you. If it has to go on the roof, trunk forward, real straps, and a second check after the first corner.
Sources: ADAC Nordbayern.
Published:
More from this section
The AvtoGear weekly
Once a week: new tests, the best deals and one useful tip for your car. Nothing extra.


