In short

  • A tow bar cargo box sits on the ball, not on the roof. Its limit is your car’s nose weight (Stützlast), and the carrier itself counts.
  • ADAC: carrier weight plus load must stay within the nose weight. It is in your registration document, field 13. If the car and carrier limits differ, the lower one counts.
  • If the box hides your plate or lights, you need a second plate and lights on the carrier. Check this before the first trip.

A roof box is the classic. But it needs roof rails, a ladder to load and it adds height. A tow bar box is the other way: low, easy to reach and no roof load. What fits in it, and what limits do you have?

How it works

The box or open carrier clamps on your tow ball. The load pushes down on the ball. That downward force is the nose weight (Stützlast). Your car and your tow bar have a maximum for it.

The limit that matters: nose weight

  • Find the limit in the registration document (Zulassungsbescheinigung Teil I), field 13, says ADAC.
  • Some makers give a lower limit for a carrier than for a trailer. Check the owner’s manual too.
  • ADAC rule: carrier weight plus load must not exceed the nose weight.
  • If car, tow bar and carrier give different figures, the lowest value is the one that counts.
  • A retailer test notes carriers are often rated up to about 60 kg. Check your own box and your own car.

ADAC also points out that loads on a rear carrier add weight to the rear axle. Heavy things at the back push the load there. Spread weight low and close to the car.

Tow bar box vs roof box

  • Loading: low and easy. No lifting over your head.
  • Roof: needs roof rails or a rack and obeys the roof load limit in your manual.
  • Boot access: many tow bar carriers tilt or swing away. Check yours before you buy.
  • Height: the car stays low for garages and car parks.
  • Length: the car gets longer. Parking sensors and reversing need care.
  • Tow bar needed: if you have none, fitting one costs money. That decides it for many people.

Rules you must know

If the carrier or load covers your rear lights or plate, you need to copy them. Manufacturers say a second plate with your registration is needed, and the carrier must carry lights that work. The plug must match your car, 7 or 13 pin. Rules differ by country, so check yours.

Thule says the combined weight must never exceed the permitted tow bar capacity. The overall length or height may change too.

Step by step

Mistakes to avoid

  • Forgetting the box counts toward the limit.
  • Ignoring the rear axle load.
  • Hiding the plate or lights.
  • Not checking tailgate access.
  • Overloading a rear box because it looks big.

Alternatives. A roof box if you have rails and no tow bar. Inside the car with a boot organiser. Or a small trailer.

Do the math: Say your limit is 75 kg and your carrier weighs 18 kg. That leaves 57 kg for the box and its contents. A 10 kg box leaves 47 kg of luggage. If you ignore this and load 60 kg, you are over the limit before you leave. These are example numbers, so use your own from field 13.

FAQ

Where do I find my nose weight? In the registration document, field 13, and the owner’s manual, says ADAC.

Does the box weight count? Yes. ADAC says carrier weight plus load must stay within the nose weight.

Do I need a second plate? If the carrier hides your plate or lights, yes. Check your local rules.

Ivan’s Take

If I already had a tow bar, I would use a tow bar box for heavy, low stuff. I would check the nose weight first and treat the box itself as part of the load. Worth it with a tow bar, not worth buying a tow bar just for it.

Sources: ADAC: Stützlast, was mit Anhänger und Fahrradträger zu beachten ist; ADAC: Fahrradträger für die Anhängerkupplung im Test; Thule: Montageanleitung Heckbox/Träger.

Published:

More from this section

The AvtoGear weekly

Once a week: new tests, the best deals and one useful tip for your car. Nothing extra.