In short
- In Germany, Austria and Switzerland you must clear snow and ice from the roof, windows, lights and number plates before you drive.
- Germany typically fines €25, Switzerland several hundred francs, and in Austria you are liable if falling snow causes a crash.
- A snow brush that won the Auto Bild test costs from €4.99.
Cold morning, ten centimetres of snow, you’re late. You scrape the windscreen and leave the roof. What could happen? At the first hard brake the snow slides forward over your windscreen. On the motorway it lifts off as a slab and hits the car behind. That is why the rules are strict, and why five minutes with a brush beat any excuse.
What happens to roof snow
Snow on the roof does not stay put. ADAC and ÖAMTC both warn that it comes loose suddenly when you pull away, brake or take a corner. Brake hard and it lands on your windscreen, blinding you in a second. Speed up and it blows off in chunks into the traffic behind you.
Ice is worse than fresh snow. A frozen sheet from a roof can crack a windscreen or cause the driver behind to swerve. Big roofs on SUVs and vans carry more of it.
The rules in Germany, Austria and Switzerland
- Germany. ADAC is clear: indicators, rear lights, headlights, number plates and the roof must be free of snow and ice before you set off. The legal basis is the driver’s general duty under § 23 StVO to drive a vehicle in proper condition with a clear view. The typical fine is €25. Scraping only a small peephole in the windscreen is not enough either.
- Austria. ÖAMTC says the roof must be cleared along with lights and plates. If snow falling from your roof causes an accident, you can be held liable. Driving with a windscreen only partly scraped can cost up to €10,000 in extreme cases.
- Switzerland. TCS says all windows, headlights and mirrors must be cleared, plus the sensors of driver assistance systems. Driving with snow on the roof or with even partly iced windows can bring a fine of several hundred francs.
Elsewhere in Europe the wording differs, but the principle is the same everywhere: you must see and be seen, and your car must not endanger others. Clear the whole car and you are safe in every country.
The right tool
You don’t need anything fancy. You need reach and a soft brush.
- Snow brush with ice scraper. Auto Bild’s ice scraper test was won by a Nigrin snow brush, available from €4.99. Wide brush, ice teeth, rubber grip.
- Telescopic snow brush. For SUVs, vans and roof boxes. Typical shop prices run from about €12 to €25. Look for a swivel head and a rubber lip for pulling snow.
- Good ice scraper. The TCS 2026 scraper test winner costs about €5. See our ice scraper test summary.
Avoid metal shovels and hard garden brooms. They scratch the paint and can damage roof seals.
Clear your car in 5 steps
Mistakes to avoid
- Leaving the engine idling while you clear. It is an offence in Germany and Switzerland, it wastes fuel and the engine warms up slowly at idle anyway.
- Hot water on the windscreen. The temperature shock can crack the glass.
- Forgetting the roof box. Snow on a roof box flies off just like roof snow.
- Clearing at the last minute. Plan five extra minutes on snowy mornings. A frost cover on the windscreen saves time.
Who should pay extra attention
SUV and van owners, because you often can’t see the roof and a normal brush doesn’t reach the middle. Anyone who parks outside overnight. And drivers heading to the Alps, where Austrian and Swiss police check more often in winter.
Do the math: Snow brush: from €4.99. Telescopic brush for a tall car: about €12 to €25. One German fine of €25 pays for five test-winning brushes. A Swiss fine of several hundred francs pays for a brush for the whole street. And if roof snow causes a crash in Austria, the bill is open-ended. The cheapest option is always the brush.
FAQ
Do I have to clear the roof if I only drive a short way? Yes. Snow can slide down at the very first brake, on any distance.
Is a little bit of snow on the roof OK? ÖAMTC calls this one of the typical winter myths. Even a thin layer comes loose suddenly.
What about a car with a panoramic roof or roof rails? The same rule applies. Brush carefully around rails and seals, and never use metal tools on glass roofs.
Ready for winter? Check our winter emergency kit under €100 and more in Safety & Emergency.
Ivan’s Take
This one is easy. A €5 snow brush lives in my boot all winter, and the roof gets cleared first, every time. Saving two minutes is not worth a €25 fine, let alone a slab of ice on someone else’s windscreen.
Sources: ADAC: Autofahrer-Irrtümer bei Eis und Schnee; ÖAMTC: Winterliche Rechtsirrtümer; TCS: Patrouille Dezember; Auto Bild: Eiskratzer-Test.
Published:
More from this section
The AvtoGear weekly
Once a week: new tests, the best deals and one useful tip for your car. Nothing extra.


