In short

  • After ten years and 850 tested cars, the ADAC says about 70 percent are better protected against keyless theft. About 30 percent still are not.
  • Thieves need two cheap radio devices, no hacking. UWB chips in the car stop the trick.
  • Do the math: a tin or a manual switch-off costs nothing. A stolen car can cost you the car and an argument with the insurer.

Your key stays in your pocket and the car unlocks by itself. Comfortable. It is also how thieves open some cars in seconds. The ADAC has tested this for ten years and now covers 850 vehicles.

How the trick works

It is called a relay attack. One thief stands near your house and picks up the radio signal of your key. A second device near the car passes that signal on. The car thinks the key is next to it.

No hacking of the car data is needed. The weak point was made public in 2011 by ETH Zurich. It works even if the key lies at home on the shelf.

What the ADAC found

  • 850 vehicles from all major makers tested since 2016.
  • About 70 percent of them are better protected today than ten years ago.
  • About 30 percent still need improvement.
  • Once the engine runs, the car keeps going without the key for as long as fuel or battery lasts.

Which cars are safer

The fix is UWB (ultra-wide band). A chip measures the signal runtime and so the real distance of the key. With the ADAC radio extender the car no longer reacts.

Jaguar Land Rover was first in 2018 (Range Rover, Range Rover Sport, Discovery, E-Pace, I-Pace). The VW group followed in 2019 with Audi A3, Seat Leon, Škoda Octavia and Golf 8. The ADAC also lists models with better protection from Cupra, BMW, Genesis, GWM, Hyundai, Kia, Mercedes and Suzuki.

In the ADAC test, no protection was found on any tested model of these makers: Aiways, Alfa Romeo, Alpine, BYD, Chevrolet, DS Automobiles, Fiat, Honda, Infiniti, Isuzu, Jeep, KGM/SsangYong, Lynk & Co, MG, Opel, Subaru and Tesla.

A motion sensor in the key is not ideal either. The signal switches off only after some time, and a theft is still possible before that.

What you can do today

  • Check the manual. Many cars let you switch keyless off. You lose comfort, you keep the car.
  • Park in a closed garage at night if you can.
  • Keep the key away from outer doors, outer walls and windows.
  • Shield the key: a metal biscuit tin, a shielding case, a cooking pot or aluminium foil can work, but only if the key is fully covered.
  • Test it. Lock the car with the key inside the shield and check that the car does not open. If it opens, the shield is useless.

Mistakes to avoid

Trusting a pouch because it says anti-theft on the label. Test it with your own car. A worn pouch can fail, so repeat the test now and then.

Buying electronic retrofit locks. The ADAC says they often use an extra keyless system that is as easy to bypass as the original one.

Do the math: A biscuit tin you already own costs €0 and the test takes half a minute. A shielding pouch costs a few euros, so test it before you rely on it. On the other side is the loss of the car. A second blow: the police find a stolen car without break-in traces, and the insurer may start asking questions.

FAQ

Is my car on the ADAC list? The ADAC publishes a list of tested models, a PDF with login. Check there or ask your dealer if your model uses UWB.

Does it matter if the key is inside the house? Yes. The weak point works even when the key lies at home. Keep it away from doors and windows.

Is a motion sensor in the key enough? The ADAC says no. Theft stays possible until the signal switches off.

Ivan’s Take

If your car has keyless and no UWB, treat the key like cash. I would use a tin at night, test it once, and ask the next dealer straight whether the car has UWB before I buy. A shielding pouch is fine, a pouch you never tested is not.

Sources: ADAC – Keyless-Systeme im Test.

Published:

More from this section

The AvtoGear weekly

Once a week: new tests, the best deals and one useful tip for your car. Nothing extra.