In short

  • The BGH ruled on 15 May 2018 (VI ZR 233/17): permanent, no-reason dash cam recording is unlawful under data protection law.
  • The same court let the footage in as evidence in a civil accident case, after weighing the interests. It is not automatic.
  • The money angle: a dash cam can decide who pays after a crash, but a cam that records everything forever creates a legal risk for you.

Is a dash cam legal in Germany? Short answer: it depends on how it records. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) ruled in 2018 that permanent recording of all traffic is not allowed. And in the same ruling it said the video could still be used in court. Confused? Here is what the court really said.

The short answer: In Germany permanent dash cam recording breaches data protection law, but the BGH (VI ZR 233/17) still allowed the footage as evidence in a civil accident case.

What the BGH decided

The case: two cars collided while turning left side by side in town. Each driver said the other left the lane. The plaintiff had a dash cam in his car. The lower courts refused the video because it broke data protection law.

The BGH (6th Civil Senate, judgment of 15 May 2018, VI ZR 233/17) split the question in two.

  • Data protection: the recording was unlawful. It broke § 4 BDSG, because nobody consented and it could not rest on § 6b Abs. 1 or § 28 Abs. 1 BDSG.
  • Why: a permanent recording of everything along the route is not necessary to secure evidence. A short recording around the accident is technically possible.
  • Evidence: the video was still usable in the civil accident case. An unlawful recording does not automatically mean the court must ignore it. The judge weighs the interests.

The court named the technical way out itself: overwrite the recording again and again in short intervals, and save it permanently only when there is a collision or a hard deceleration.

Why the court let the video in

  • The recording shows events on a public road that anybody can see.
  • Accident analysis often lacks reliable facts. Evidence is hard to get.
  • Data protection law has its own tools against the recorder: fines, and orders from the supervisory authority.

The BGH also noted that violations of data protection law can lead to high fines. Deliberate acts for payment, or with the intent to enrich or harm, can even mean prison. So the court did not wave the recording through. It separated two questions: is the cam lawful, and may the court use the footage?

One thing to keep in mind

The ruling dates from before the GDPR applied (25 May 2018) and rests on the old BDSG. It was a civil case about liability after an accident. It does not tell you how a criminal court or a fine authority would treat your footage. I am not a lawyer, and this is not legal advice.

How to use a dash cam sensibly

  • Use loop recording that overwrites old clips quickly. That is what the BGH describes as the data-friendly way.
  • Use a shock sensor that locks the clip on impact or hard braking. Only that clip stays.
  • Keep the buffer short. You need the minutes around the crash, not the whole trip.
  • Do not store a growing archive of every drive.
  • Do not post clips online. The BGH ruling is about evidence, not about publishing.

Fitting it

§ 23 Abs. 1 StVO makes the driver responsible that view and hearing are not impaired by equipment or the state of the vehicle. Mount the cam so it does not block your view. Behind the rear-view mirror is the usual spot.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Recording every drive and keeping everything. That is exactly the permanent recording the court called unlawful.
  • Believing the footage always wins in court. The judge weighs it each time.
  • Showing or posting the video to others, because it is funny or because somebody drove badly.
  • A cam mounted in the middle of your field of view.

Do the math: Take an example repair bill of €4,000, a made-up number. In the case before the BGH, the first court gave the plaintiff half of the damage because he could not prove who left the lane. Half of €4,000 is €2,000 out of your pocket. Footage that the court accepts can change that split.

FAQ

Is permanent dash cam recording legal in Germany? No. The BGH held that permanent, no-reason recording breaks data protection law and is not necessary for securing evidence.

Can I use my dash cam footage in court? In the civil accident case before the BGH, yes, after weighing the interests. It is decided case by case.

Can I be fined? The BGH noted that data protection violations can lead to high fines and measures by the supervisory authority.

Ivan’s Take

A dash cam is useful, but only the right kind of recording. I would set it to loop, let the shock sensor save the clip and never build an archive. That gives you evidence when it counts and keeps you on the right side of the 2018 ruling.

Sources: Bundesgerichtshof, Pressemitteilung Nr. 088/2018 (VI ZR 233/17); StVO § 23 (gesetze-im-internet.de).

Published:

More from this section

The AvtoGear weekly

Once a week: new tests, the best deals and one useful tip for your car. Nothing extra.