In short
- ADAC tested 16 winter tyres in 225/50 R17, the mid-size class (Audi A4, BMW 3 Series, Mercedes C-Class). Four got “good”, six failed.
- Winner: Pirelli Cinturato Winter 3, grade 2.2, about €149. Continental WinterContact TS 870 (2.3, €150), Goodyear UltraGrip Performance 3 (2.4, €148) and Michelin Alpin 7 (2.5, €165) follow.
- Money angle: a €61 to €85 set looks like a bargain, but the three cheapest tyres failed with grades of 5.4 and 5.5.
Winter tyres are not about snow only. Most of the winter in central Europe is cold, wet and dry asphalt. ADAC and its partners just tested 16 winter tyres in 225/50 R17 in Finland and on a proving ground. The headline: four good tyres, six that fail, and one tyre that is the best on snow and still scores 5.5 overall.
How ADAC tested
ADAC fitted the 16 tyres in turns to an Audi A4 Avant. Snow and ice handling was tested in Ivalo in Finland. Dry and wet tests, aquaplaning and noise followed on other tracks. The overall grade is 70% driving safety and 30% environment (mileage, abrasion, efficiency, noise).
For winter tyres the safety part splits like this: dry road 30%, wet road 40%, wintry road 30%. That weighting matters. Most of your winter driving is not snow, so a tyre must brake and steer well on a cold wet road first. Lower grades are better: 1.6 to 2.5 is good, 2.6 to 3.5 satisfactory, 4.6 and above poor.
The winner and the top picks
- Pirelli Cinturato Winter 3: grade 2.2, about €149. Best driving safety in the test (2.1), top in the wet with short braking distance and high aquaplaning reserves.
- Continental WinterContact TS 870: grade 2.3, about €150. Very safe, short braking distances on dry and wet roads, a bit less precise on dry roads and in snow handling.
- Goodyear UltraGrip Performance 3: grade 2.4, about €148. High mileage and a balanced performance, with only small weaknesses on snow and ice.
- Michelin Alpin 7: grade 2.5, about €165. Excellent on winter roads, a less precise steering feel on dry asphalt keeps it from ranking higher.
Satisfactory middle field, grades 2.6 to 3.1: Bridgestone Blizzak 6 (2.6, €143), Hankook Winter i*cept RS3 (2.7, €122), ESA+TECAR Supergrip Pro2 (2.7, sold only in Switzerland), Dunlop Winter (2.9, €120), Yokohama BluEarth Winter V906 (3.1, €98) and Vredestein Wintrac Pro+ (3.1, €114).
Six tyres fail
Six tyres got grades between 4.8 and 5.5: Falken Eurowinter HS02 Pro (4.8, €108), Toyo Observe EWS1 (5.3, €108), Tracmax Ice-Plus S210 (5.4, €68), Aptany RW211 (5.4, €61), Royal Black Royalwinter UHP (5.5, €85) and Sunwide Snowide (5.5, €116). Mostly budget brands, but also two well-known names, Falken and Toyo.
The Sunwide is the strangest case. It is the best tyre on snow in the test (1.3), with excellent braking on snow and ice. But on dry and wet roads it is extremely vague and weak. On the wet it needs almost 12 metres more to stop than the Continental or the Pirelli, which stop from 80 km/h in about 35 metres. At the point where the best tyres stand still, the Sunwide still rolls at about 40 km/h. 12 metres is roughly three car lengths.
Who it is for
- You drive in cities and on motorways, with little snow: Pirelli, Continental or Goodyear. Wet braking is what you use most.
- You live in the mountains or drive in snow often: Michelin Alpin 7 is the one that ADAC praises on winter roads.
- You want the best value for the environment: Dunlop Winter has the lowest abrasion and the best predicted mileage of the field, about 59,300 km, at about €120.
Mistakes to avoid
- Buying a winter tyre because it is great on snow. The Sunwide shows that this is not enough.
- Trusting a known brand blindly. Falken and Toyo both fail in this test.
- Buying the cheapest set from an online marketplace. The cheapest tyres, Aptany and Tracmax, scored 5.4.
- Keeping tyres too long. ADAC recommends replacing winter tyres once the tread is below 4 mm.
Do the math: Pirelli Cinturato Winter 3: 4 x €149 = €596. Aptany RW211: 4 x €61 = €244. You save €352, and you get grade 5.4, poor. Dunlop Winter: 4 x €120 = €480 for about 59,300 km, roughly 0.8 cents per km. A middle path: Hankook Winter i*cept RS3, 4 x €122 = €488, grade 2.7. That is €108 less than the Pirelli for a satisfactory tyre.
FAQ
Do the results apply to other sizes? Mostly yes if width differs by at most 10 mm, the aspect ratio by at most 5 points and the rim size is the same. Tyres with speed index V or higher do not carry over to lower indexes.
Is a premium tyre always better? No. The Michelin Alpin 7 costs about €165 and is rated 2.5. The Pirelli is €16 cheaper and rated 2.2. Check the grades, not the badge.
When should I replace winter tyres? ADAC recommends replacing them once the tread is below 4 mm. The legal minimum is lower, but grip on snow and wet roads falls fast.
Ivan’s Take
The Pirelli is the safe buy at about €149, and the Continental is the same story. The Goodyear is the one I would pick if I drive a lot. Stay away from everything under €100 in this test. A winter tyre that fails on wet roads is not a saving, it is a bet. I would not take that bet with my family in the car.
Sources: ADAC Winterreifentest 225/50 R17 (2026).
Published:
More from this section
The AvtoGear weekly
Once a week: new tests, the best deals and one useful tip for your car. Nothing extra.


