In short

  • ADAC tested 16 all-season tyres in 225/45 R17 in summer, in winter and in the wet. Four got “good”, four failed with “poor”.
  • Winners: Continental AllSeasonContact 2 and Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3, both grade 2.3, both about €135. Pirelli and Bridgestone follow with 2.5.
  • Money angle: the Goodyear lasts about 68,000 km, so a cheaper set at €83 would need two sets for the same distance.

One set, no swapping, no storage. That is the promise of all-season tyres. But can they keep it? ADAC says: only some can. In its test of 16 all-season tyres in 225/45 R17, a size for compact and mid-size cars, four tyres are good, four are barely sufficient and four fail completely. The good news is that a year earlier only one tyre got a good grade. Now there are four.

How ADAC tested

ADAC tested the 16 tyres in summer conditions, on wet roads and in winter conditions in Finland. Part of the program ran on the Contidrom near Hannover. Dry driving, wet driving, braking, handling, aquaplaning and snow and ice: all on one set of tyres.

The overall grade is 70% driving safety and 30% environment. For all-season tyres the safety part is weighted: dry road 35%, wet road 45%, wintry road 20%. Lower is better: 1.6 to 2.5 is good, 2.6 to 3.5 satisfactory, 3.6 to 4.5 sufficient, 4.6 and above poor.

The winners and the top picks

  • Continental AllSeasonContact 2: grade 2.3, about €135. The only tyre that is good in both pillars, safety (2.4) and environment (2.2). No weaknesses on dry or wet roads, good winter ability, the shortest wet braking distance in the test.
  • Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3: grade 2.3, about €135. Excellent in wet braking and handling, a little less precise in summer heat. Best environment grade of the group (1.6) and the longest predicted mileage, about 68,000 km.
  • Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3: grade 2.5, about €127. Safe, loses a little on wintry roads.
  • Bridgestone Turanza All Season 6: grade 2.5, about €126. Safe, also gives up a little on wintry roads.

These four solve the basic conflict of an all-season tyre: good grip in summer heat and good grip on ice and snow in the cold. That conflict is the reason why most all-season tyres used to be a compromise.

Recommended with a catch

Four more tyres are satisfactory: Michelin CrossClimate 2 (2.7, about €145), Dunlop All Season 2 (2.9, about €123), BFGoodrich Advantage All-Season (2.9, about €129) and Viking FourTech Plus (3.0, no price given). Michelin, Dunlop and BFGoodrich are strongest on wintry roads. The Dunlop also scores well in the environment grade (1.6). The Viking is neither good nor bad at anything, so the price can decide.

Four tyres fail

CST Medallion All Season ACP1 (4.8, about €81), APlus AS909 (4.9, about €84), Arivo Carlorful A/S (5.5, about €72) and Petlas Multi Action PT565 (5.5, about €97) all get poor. They are mostly sold online. Grip is missing on wintry roads (CST and Petlas) or on wet roads (Arivo and APlus). As all-season tyres they are simply unsuitable.

Brand names do not save you. Four more tyres only get sufficient: Vredestein Quatrac Pro+ (3.8, about €121), Barum Quartaris 5 (3.9, about €107), Nexen N’Blue 4Season 2 (3.9, about €104) and Superia Ecoblue2 4S (3.9, about €83). The Barum is the budget brand of Continental, and it shows on dry roads.

The braking numbers are the scary part. On wet roads from 80 km/h, the best tyre (Continental) and the worst (Arivo) are 11.3 metres apart. When the car on the Continental has stopped, the one on the Arivo still hits an obstacle at 41 km/h.

Who it is for

  • You drive mostly in cities and on motorways, with some snow: Continental or Goodyear. One set, no seasonal change.
  • You live where winters are really snowy or you drive in the mountains: a dedicated winter tyre is still the safer choice on deep snow.
  • You want a low cost per km: Goodyear, with the longest mileage in the test.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Trusting the label. A tyre sold as all-season has to prove it on wet roads and in winter. Four of the 16 did not.
  • Buying an online no-name at €72 to €97. Four of them failed, and the saving is not worth a 41 km/h crash.
  • Assuming a budget brand of a premium maker is the same tyre. The Barum, from Continental, got 3.9.
  • Forgetting that the test covers one size. Check that your size is within the ADAC transfer rules: width plus or minus 10 mm, aspect ratio plus or minus 5 points, same rim.

Do the math: Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3: 4 x €135 = €540 for about 68,000 km, roughly 0.8 cents per km. Superia Ecoblue2 4S: 4 x €83 = €332, but you need about two sets for the same distance, so €664, and you get a sufficient grade. The “cheap” set costs you about €124 more. The Arivo at 4 x €72 = €288 saves €252 against the Continental, and costs you 11.3 metres of braking distance.

FAQ

Do all-season tyres replace winter tyres? Only the good ones, and only if you drive in mild winters. The test shows that the best four manage both summer and winter. The failed ones do not.

Are the results valid for my size? If your size is close to 225/45 R17 and the rim is the same, mostly yes. Other sizes can behave differently.

Is a premium brand always better? No. The Michelin CrossClimate 2 costs about €145 and gets 2.7. The Pirelli is about €18 cheaper and gets 2.5.

Ivan’s Take

Two tyres at about €135 deserve the money: Continental AllSeasonContact 2 if you want the safest, Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3 if you want the lowest cost per kilometre. Everything with a grade under 3.0 is a compromise, and everything under €100 in this test is a risk. I would buy one good all-season set and stop swapping wheels twice a year.

Sources: ADAC Ganzjahresreifen 225/45 R17 (2025).

Published:

More from this section

The AvtoGear weekly

Once a week: new tests, the best deals and one useful tip for your car. Nothing extra.