In short

  • ADAC tested 32 winter tyres in two sizes: 185/65 R15 for small cars and 225/50 R17 for mid-size cars.
  • Small cars: only 2 of 16 are good. Continental WinterContact TS 870 is best in the whole test (2.2), Michelin Alpin 7 second (2.5). Nine are not recommended.
  • Mid-size: Pirelli Cinturato Winter 3 wins (2.2), ahead of Continental (2.3). Goodyear and Michelin are also good. Six of 16 are deficient.

If you are buying winter tyres this month, this is the test to read before you pay. The ADAC result is blunt: there are many winter tyres, but only a few are really good.

Small cars (185/65 R15)

  • Continental WinterContact TS 870: 2.2, best of all 32. Balanced on dry, wet, snow and ice, decent environmental score.
  • Michelin Alpin 7: 2.5. Good safety, small minus in snow handling.
  • Deficient (mangelhaft): Sunny Winter-max NW611, Atlas Polarbear HP and Rockblade Rock 868S, because of weak driving safety.

Nine of 16 small-car tyres cannot be recommended. Mileage is also short in this size: about 31,000 km on average, and the Bridgestone in the test only about 22,000 km.

Mid-size cars (225/50 R17)

  • Pirelli Cinturato Winter 3: 2.2, test winner, very strong on wet roads.
  • Continental WinterContact TS 870: 2.3, close second.
  • Goodyear and Michelin: also good overall.
  • Six of 16 are deficient. Their common weakness: at least one surface where they are so bad it is a safety issue.

Average expected mileage in this size is over 45,000 km, much better than the small-car size.

What this means when you buy

  • Do not buy on price alone. ADAC saw that some cheaper tyres are good on one surface and dangerous on another.
  • If you drive a lot, look at mileage and wear too, not only the safety grade.
  • Replace winter tyres under 4 mm tread or older than 8 years (ADAC).
  • Your size is probably not one of the two tested. Use the brand and model results as a guide, and check tests in your size.

Do the math: in the Auto Bild price list for size 205/55 R16, the Pirelli Cinturato Winter 3 costs about 96 euros and the Kumho WinterCraft WP52+ about 63 euros per tyre. That is about 33 euros per tyre, around 130 euros for a set of four, spread over 4 to 5 winters. Roughly 30 euros a year for the tyre that stops shortest is cheap insurance.

Our tyre basics

How much tread you really need and how to check it with a 1 euro coin: Tyre tread: 1.6 mm is legal, 4 mm is safe in winter. Check yours with a 1 euro coin.

FAQ

Which winter tyre won the ADAC test for small cars? Continental WinterContact TS 870 scored 2.2, the best of all 32 tyres tested. Michelin Alpin 7 came second with 2.5, and only 2 of the 16 small-car tyres are good.

Which winter tyre is best for mid-size cars in the ADAC test? Pirelli Cinturato Winter 3 wins with 2.2, ahead of Continental with 2.3. Goodyear and Michelin are also good, but six of 16 tyres in this size are deficient.

When should I replace my winter tyres? ADAC says to replace winter tyres under 4 mm tread or older than 8 years. Do not buy on price alone, because some cheaper tyres are good on one surface and dangerous on another.

Ivan’s Take

I buy tyres the way I buy parts: price matters, but only after it works. A tyre graded deficient on ice is not a bargain at any price. For a small car I would go straight to the Continental, for a bigger car Pirelli or Continental. Then I would compare prices across shops, because the same tyre often costs very different money.

Sources: ADAC; Auto Bild.

Published:

More from this section

The AvtoGear weekly

Once a week: new tests, the best deals and one useful tip for your car. Nothing extra.